Hey Reader,Last week I told you about the walkthrough videos we made for Wyndham. They went from 45 quick seconds to 2 slow minutes the moment we found out who'd be watching. That lesson didn't start with Wyndham. I learned it the hard way, years before. Back in 2018, a client came to me about a video for their dinner. Nothing was scripted yet. I hadn't shot a frame. We were just talking it through. They wanted something long. Nine, ten minutes. I pushed back right away. Ten minutes is boring, I told them. People won't sit for that. Let me make you something short and tight. I fought for shorter the way I usually do. The client heard me out and then said the thing that's stuck with me ever since. These people are sitting down. They came for this. They gave up their night because they care about it. The video was a window into the organization's work over in Israel, made for a room full of Americans who'd never seen that side of it. A whole world they were passionate about but had never actually watched up close. For that room, ten minutes was barely enough. They wanted more. By the end of that conversation, I'd come around completely. I was totally wrong. And I LOVE being wrong when I actually learn something from it. That one reset how I think about length for good. On my timeline…Here's what I got backwards, and what I think a lot of editors get backwards. I was treating length like a fixed rule. Shorter is better. Cut it down, always. That instinct makes sense on a video that's fighting to keep somebody's attention while their thumb hovers over the next thing. Some of what I make lives in exactly that world. But a lot of what we focus on are stories you can let breathe. A brand film sitting on a website. A piece being presented to an investor. Those can take their time. So did this one. Nobody in that room was scrolling. Nobody was deciding every three seconds whether to stay. They were seated, fed, invested, and rooting for the thing on screen. It's the same question I keep coming back to, the one about who's actually in the room when a video plays. Once I understood who was watching and why they'd come, the right length stopped being a number I could decide on my own. It became a question about the room. Long doesn't scare me anymore. Short can still drag, and long can still fly. It's become kind of a thing between Laibel and me by now. Whenever we're talking through a project, I'll ask, "Okay, how long does this video need to be?" And these days I just answer it myself. "However long it needs to be." It sounds like a dodge, but it's the real answer. Five minutes, six, ten, whatever the piece needs for the people who'll actually watch it, in the room where they'll watch it. Featured work…Without further ado, here's the actual video. The dinner film for Mosdos Karlin Stolin. It runs just over 9 minutes. The perfect length for the job. Watch for where it slows down on purpose. The beats I'd cut from a video made for a phone are exactly the beats that work here. Quick cut…You don't need another plugin. You probably need another pass through the story. Most of the time the fix was never going to come from the software. Coming up…Somebody reached out to me recently, looking for inspiration. He's launching a new brand for a healthcare product and wanted some references. Next week I'll share what I told him. It's a different way of looking for inspiration, and it works on any project. Avraham P.S. I'm curious this week: what's the longest video you've ever kept someone watching all the way through? Hit reply, I want to know. P.P.S. If someone you know is somewhere near this world, editing, design, photo, marketing, just curious, forward this to them. That's how this thing grows. |
Video editing, storytelling, breakdowns, and conversations for people who want to understand what makes videos work. Join the list and I'll send you my weekly newsletter on the decisions behind the edit.
Hey Reader, Fair warning: this one's about a website. Hang tight, though, because it comes right back around to video. Back in 2022 I had an idea for a website. For years I've edited Sruly Shain's weekly 2 Minutes 4 Torah, a two-minute Dvar Torah that goes out to a WhatsApp group every week. Hundreds of episodes, and no real home for them. I wanted one place where you could find any episode, search it, and watch it by parsha. So I opened a Webflow account and designed the whole thing. I even...
Hey Reader, Last week I told you to know which job your video has before you go looking for references. Here's what happens when you skip that step. Someone I've been mentoring was working on a video for a client. The pieces were there, and something still wasn't landing. It was trying to be three things at once. Part brand film, part sales pitch, part explainer. Reaching for all three, it never fully became any one of them. So I asked her the question I ask myself at the start of every...
Hey Reader, A little while ago somebody reached out to me looking for inspiration. He's launching a new brand for a healthcare product, and he wanted references. Videos that looked like the one he needed to make. I get why. It's the first thing almost everyone does. Search for your exact category, find the best one out there, and aim for that. Here's the problem. Even if you find the perfect match, you'll end up making something that feels borrowed. Everyone in your industry has seen the same...