One question saved me days of work


Hey Reader,

Somewhere in the middle of prepping a new edit last month, a question popped into my head.

I almost waved it off. I already knew this project. I'd been carrying the brief around in my head for a year.

But the question wouldn't leave:

"Who's going to be in the room when this plays?"

And the answer changed everything.


On my timeline…

A while back, we created a brand film for Special Children's Center about their farm. The who, what, when, where of the place.

We filmed it over the summer, so the summer program naturally became a big part of it. Camp energy. Counselors. Girls growing through the work.

The plan now was simple: same farm, different version. This one tailored for the Lakewood community, featuring the boys and the year-round program.

In my head, the structure was already set. It's the structure I use for most donor-facing films:

Hook. Problem. Solution. Then go deeper.

That was the brief. From a year ago.

But by the time I actually sat down to edit, one detail had changed.

This video wasn't going to play at a fundraiser or land in donors' inboxes.

It was going to be shown at a Siyum. A Siyum the boys were making. On the farm.

Which means the boys would be sitting right there, watching it.

That's when the question hit.

Because here's the thing about my trusty hook-problem-solution structure: in a donor video, "the problem" is the engine. You show the need, then you show the answer.

But play that same video in front of these boys, and the message becomes:

"You are the problem. We are the solution to you."

That's not just the wrong structure.

That's condescending.

So the structure went out the window.

No problem section. No origin-story rabbit hole about how the farm was founded.

Straight to the celebration.

What the farm is doing for these boys. How well they're integrating. The learning, the davening, the growth — spiritual as much as physical.

(I do touch on their challenges. These boys are self-aware, and pretending otherwise would be its own kind of dishonesty. But it's a touch, not a thesis.)

A video like this takes two or three days of editing. If I had built it the way the year-old brief in my head wanted, I would've spent a couple of days getting comfortable with the edit — and then re-cut entire sections once I realized what the room actually needed.

One question. A day or more of work saved.

And something more important than time: the right film.


Featured work…

I'll give you one guess what this week's featured project is.

On paper, it's the same farm as the original film. Same place. Some of the same people.

A completely different film.

The challenge here wasn't footage. It was framing. The audience changed, so the meaning had to change.

If you watch it, notice what isn't there. There's no problem being set up. No need waiting for a solution.

The film celebrates without explaining.

→ Watch the film If you can't access Vimeo, here's an alt. link​


Quick cut…

Taste is choosing. Software is executing.

Don't confuse the two.


Coming up…

There's a much bigger conversation hiding underneath this issue.

Before I edit anything, I ask a lot of questions. Where will this be shown? Who's watching? What should they feel? What should they do?

Honestly — it's a million and one questions. And I've found that the deeper I understand a project, the better the work gets.

That's a topic for its own issue. Soon.

In the meantime, this exact kind of thinking is what the live workshop on Sunday, June 28 at 3:00 PM EST is all about. Editing, storytelling, sound design, AI, creative process, client work, and real-world decision making.

Less tutorial. More sitting in the edit suite together.

→ Register for the Workshop​

— Avraham

P.S. Don't be a stranger. I read every reply and would LOVE to hear from you.


The Cutting Corner

Video editing, storytelling, breakdowns, and conversations for people who want to understand what makes videos work. Join the list and I'll send you my weekly newsletter on the decisions behind the edit.

Read more from The Cutting Corner
ketch of Avraham beside "26."; the 2022 website design up top, the live 2026 site below, and "2022 → 2026" between them.

Hey Reader, Fair warning: this one's about a website. Hang tight, though, because it comes right back around to video. Back in 2022 I had an idea for a website. For years I've edited Sruly Shain's weekly 2 Minutes 4 Torah, a two-minute Dvar Torah that goes out to a WhatsApp group every week. Hundreds of episodes, and no real home for them. I wanted one place where you could find any episode, search it, and watch it by parsha. So I opened a Webflow account and designed the whole thing. I even...

Sketch of Avraham beside "25."; "What kind of video is this?" over Brand film, Sales video and Explainer, all ticked: "Pick one."

Hey Reader, Last week I told you to know which job your video has before you go looking for references. Here's what happens when you skip that step. Someone I've been mentoring was working on a video for a client. The pieces were there, and something still wasn't landing. It was trying to be three things at once. Part brand film, part sales pitch, part explainer. Reaching for all three, it never fully became any one of them. So I asked her the question I ask myself at the start of every...

Sketch of Avraham beside "24."; "Steal from the next aisle." over a crossed-out "Your category" sign and a "Coffee, cars, watches" sign.

Hey Reader, A little while ago somebody reached out to me looking for inspiration. He's launching a new brand for a healthcare product, and he wanted references. Videos that looked like the one he needed to make. I get why. It's the first thing almost everyone does. Search for your exact category, find the best one out there, and aim for that. Here's the problem. Even if you find the perfect match, you'll end up making something that feels borrowed. Everyone in your industry has seen the same...