She didn't know what she was making


Hey Reader,

Last week I told you to know which job your video has before you go looking for references.

Here's what happens when you skip that step.

Someone I've been mentoring was working on a video for a client. The pieces were there, and something still wasn't landing.

It was trying to be three things at once. Part brand film, part sales pitch, part explainer. Reaching for all three, it never fully became any one of them.

So I asked her the question I ask myself at the start of every project now. What kind of video is this?

On my timeline…

A brand film and a sales video are close cousins, which is what makes them tricky.

A brand film is often aspirational. It shows what the brand is about without over-explaining or going into too much detail. Nike never tells you to buy the shoes. You want them by the end anyway.

A sales video shares a lot of that DNA, with a more salesy twist. It's a little more on the nose, and the ask at the end is more direct.

Walking the line between those two is a tightrope. Push the ask too hard and the brand film turns into an ad. Hold it back too much and the sales video never asks for anything.

An explainer is a different animal. To me, that's a tutorial. It walks you through how something works, step by step, and it can go as deep as it needs to.

Once you name the type, the hard calls get easier. What goes in, what stays out, how long it runs, where it lives. A brand film can lose a whole section of information and get stronger. Take that same section out of an explainer and it breaks.

And here's the part that changed how she saw the whole thing. Most clients need a set of videos, one for each job. A brand film to pull people in. A sales video when it's time to ask. An explainer to walk people through how it works. A testimonial to earn trust. All pointing the same way.

One of those has a rule I won't bend on. A testimonial has to be real. An actual person, actually filmed. Its whole power is that it happened, so that's a place I stop reaching for AI, however good it gets.

Featured work…

Here's what that looks like in real work. HH Designers is a high-end interior design firm, and Hans Krug makes high-end kitchens. We made a set of pieces around the two of them working together, and each one had its own job.

The testimonial is from Hans Krug's side: what it's like working with HH.

The kitchen showcase shows off the finished kitchen, and it works for both companies.

"Make Something Beautiful" is 41 seconds of the build, leaning into a song I found that fits it perfectly.

"Possibilities" is the closest to a brand film. It's aspirational, all about how many possibilities a customer has, and that idea became the focus while I was editing.

None of them is trying to be all four. Knowing exactly what each one was made every decision in the edit easier.

→ Watch the set in the Corner​


Quick cut…

If you're bored, pay attention. That flat spot where your mind drifts is usually the exact place the story stops moving. The audience feels it a second after you do.


Coming up…

Next week, something a little different. A website I gave up on four years ago, and the one night it finally got built.

Avraham

P.S. What are you working on right now, and do you know which kind of video it is? Hit reply, I want to know.


The Cutting Corner

Video editing, storytelling, breakdowns, and conversations for people who want to understand what makes videos work. Join the list and I'll send you my weekly newsletter on the decisions behind the edit.

Read more from The Cutting Corner
ketch of Avraham beside "26."; the 2022 website design up top, the live 2026 site below, and "2022 → 2026" between them.

Hey Reader, Fair warning: this one's about a website. Hang tight, though, because it comes right back around to video. Back in 2022 I had an idea for a website. For years I've edited Sruly Shain's weekly 2 Minutes 4 Torah, a two-minute Dvar Torah that goes out to a WhatsApp group every week. Hundreds of episodes, and no real home for them. I wanted one place where you could find any episode, search it, and watch it by parsha. So I opened a Webflow account and designed the whole thing. I even...

Sketch of Avraham beside "24."; "Steal from the next aisle." over a crossed-out "Your category" sign and a "Coffee, cars, watches" sign.

Hey Reader, A little while ago somebody reached out to me looking for inspiration. He's launching a new brand for a healthcare product, and he wanted references. Videos that looked like the one he needed to make. I get why. It's the first thing almost everyone does. Search for your exact category, find the best one out there, and aim for that. Here's the problem. Even if you find the perfect match, you'll end up making something that feels borrowed. Everyone in your industry has seen the same...

Sketch of Avraham beside "23."; hand-lettered "How long?" over a 9:15 video bar, and "However long it needs to be."

Hey Reader, Last week I told you about the walkthrough videos we made for Wyndham. They went from 45 quick seconds to 2 slow minutes the moment we found out who'd be watching. That lesson didn't start with Wyndham. I learned it the hard way, years before. Back in 2018, a client came to me about a video for their dinner. Nothing was scripted yet. I hadn't shot a frame. We were just talking it through. They wanted something long. Nine, ten minutes. I pushed back right away. Ten minutes is...