Hey Reader,The young shooter on our team wrote me not long ago. He had a few free days and he was partway through a filmmaking course. Composition. Cuts. Transitions. Storyboarding. Cameras. Gear. Color. Audio. Business. Theory. He asked what he should practice. You could hear the overwhelm through his message. I told him to skip almost all of it. Just for that week. Then I gave him the smallest job I could think of. Pick one ordinary thing that has a start and a finish. Someone making coffee. A sofer writing. Somebody fixing a bike. Shoot it properly, then cut it to ninety seconds. That's the assignment. All of it. Here's why I keep handing out that one. A course is organized by subject, which is the only sensible way to build a course. The work doesn't show up in that order. It shows up as one small problem at a time, in an order nobody planned. You find out what a cutaway is for on the day you need one and don't have it. You feel why coverage matters while you're sitting there with three angles that refuse to cut together. So I told him to over-shoot. Five shots on every action. Hands close. The face. A wide. Over the shoulder. One angle nobody in their right mind would pick. Come back with too much and you have something to work with. That's the entire reason. And three constraints, because the constraints are what actually kill the overwhelm. One subject. One location. Ninety seconds. Done by the end of the week. Then send me the raw and your cut. That last line is the part that matters most. FINISHING is what teaches. A piece you never export teaches you nothing at all. Your turn…He went and did it. He grabbed the only subject he had on hand, himself, sat down in a room, and filmed himself opening a book and reading it. Twenty-one shots. On paper it's about as dry as footage gets. That's exactly why I love it. Everything you need is in there to turn it into something dramatic, maybe even a little over the top. So here's a challenge, if you want one. Take his twenty-one shots and make about thirty seconds out of them. Shorter is fine, a little longer is fine. The only rule is that you don't bore me for a single second. Make it dramatic. I keep hearing a deep, almost poetic voiceover over it, something about what books do to us, but take it wherever you want: the music, the sound design, the pace of the cut. It's yours. If you want to give it a try, just reply and I'll send over the footage and a short brief. Send me what you make and I'll watch every one. With your permission, I'll share a few of my favorites in a future email. (And a big thank you to him for letting me pass his footage around.) Want to go further?If thirty seconds sounds like fun and you want to go a lot further, The Cutting Room Cohort starts this coming Monday. It's the same idea at full size: one real project, carried from the first shot to a finished piece, with me next to you the whole way, on the same AI workflow I use for client work. It's small on purpose, so seats are limited. Quick cut…Good stories survive bad footage. Bad stories rarely survive good footage. Which is worth knowing before you go out and shoot something with whatever you've got. Coming up…Next week, eight lessons from working with Wyndham Hotels, one of the biggest hotel companies in the world. Layers of approvals, a legal department, the CEO watching the final cut, and a 30-second ad I pushed back on. Avraham P.S. If somebody you know is anywhere near this world, editing, design, photo, or just circling it, forward this to them. That's how this thing actually grows. |
Video editing, storytelling, breakdowns, and conversations for people who want to understand what makes videos work. Join the list and I'll send you my weekly newsletter on the decisions behind the edit.
Hey Reader, Fair warning: this one's about a website. Hang tight, though, because it comes right back around to video. Back in 2022 I had an idea for a website. For years I've edited Sruly Shain's weekly 2 Minutes 4 Torah, a two-minute Dvar Torah that goes out to a WhatsApp group every week. Hundreds of episodes, and no real home for them. I wanted one place where you could find any episode, search it, and watch it by parsha. So I opened a Webflow account and designed the whole thing. I even...
Hey Reader, Last week I told you to know which job your video has before you go looking for references. Here's what happens when you skip that step. Someone I've been mentoring was working on a video for a client. The pieces were there, and something still wasn't landing. It was trying to be three things at once. Part brand film, part sales pitch, part explainer. Reaching for all three, it never fully became any one of them. So I asked her the question I ask myself at the start of every...
Hey Reader, A little while ago somebody reached out to me looking for inspiration. He's launching a new brand for a healthcare product, and he wanted references. Videos that looked like the one he needed to make. I get why. It's the first thing almost everyone does. Search for your exact category, find the best one out there, and aim for that. Here's the problem. Even if you find the perfect match, you'll end up making something that feels borrowed. Everyone in your industry has seen the same...